We can't help you much with those everyday life decisions, but we can tell you that with ns novelties' InflataPlay Plug, you can be as undecided as you like...about the thickness of your butt plug, at least!  

This dreamy Plug starts (relatively) small and sleek but, thanks to a ribbed silicone layer over the firm core, pumps up to almost twice the thickness. Once the classic taper's in place, squeeze the bulb to inflate. Easy!

The sturdy ABS plastic and silicone Aqua Pro is body-safe, easy to clean, and safe to use with any water-based lube you love. It's USB rechargeable (the cord is included) and fully waterproof.

*The max inflated width is about 2.75"/7cm. Do not over-inflate.